Walk our Key West Neighborhoods
Before you begin your search, choose a perfect Key West neighborhood. We'll explain the best features in each neighborhood so you can match your style with your new neighbors. Click the link above to get started on your neighborhood tour.
What Brenda's Clients Say
Brenda Donnelly serves her clients as though they were friends. She's beside them each step, whether they're buyers or sellers, ensuring a smooth process from the first conversation to the final celebrations. Want to hear directly from her clients? Just click the link above.







Hurricane Irma: A personal note to my clients, friends and soon-to-be friends: 

No other city in the United States combines in just 5.5 square miles the cosmopolitan sophistication of Manhattan with the laid-back, live-and-let-live lifestyle of the historic Caribbean islands. And that exuberant, legendary Keys Strong approach is rebuilding our island in scant weeks following Hurricane Irma on Sept. 10.

Key West escaped the brunt of Hurricane Irma, emerging that Sunday afternoon with virtually every home and building standing strong. Our building codes ensure our structures can withstand the kinds of Category 4 winds that raced across the island. The storm surge was only 2.5 feet, far less than even Hurricane Wilma, and that meant little flooding throughout the island and none in most areas.

Our Island Homes Key West staff is safe. Our homes survived the storm. Our challenges are many and we are prepared Keys Strong to meet them successfully. We look forward to welcoming you to your island paradise. We are grateful for your patience as we make Key West ready for you.

We are grateful to you who share our love of this island. We need you to come “home” to Key West as part of our recovery. We might be a little less green, but our famous Key West hospitality will be better than ever.

We have inspected each of our Island Homes Key West featured homes for sale. All remain strong, safe and secure. They are as beautiful today as they were two weeks ago. Tropical landscaping recovers quickly and it will be but a few weeks before the lush, green gardens repair themselves.

We are barely two weeks into our recovery, yet home and business owners are opening doors and welcoming friends and family home. Over the next month, we will open our featured homes for your private tour. We will work with you to achieve your dreams in our Key West paradise. You already know how wonderful a Key West vacation can be. Living here is better. Sharing our indomitable spirit, becoming part of our unique community, will convince you there is no better place on earth to call home.

Whether you’re considering a permanent Key West move or a second home to escape the mainland winters, you’ll soon find yourself wondering how you lived anywhere else.

Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Knight & Gardner Realty

Let Brenda Donnelly find your perfect Key West real estate

Whether you want to spend a week in Key West, a month or a lifetime, Realtor Brenda Donnelly will help you navigate the single family and commercial Key West real estate markets or find a vacation rental.

Brenda DonnellyBrenda Donnelly is an award-winning, veteran Key West real estate agent and long-time resident. She brings more than two-decades of experience to your search for the perfect single family home, vacation rental or commercial property. Brenda is an agent with one of Key West’s premier luxury homes real estate companies, Berkshire Hathaway Home Services Knight & Gardner Realty,

  • Island Homes Key West will find your perfect home or business;
  • Historic Key West Vacation Rentals offers vacation rentals from a few days to a full season;
  • Inn Touch In Key West is our concierge service that will help you plan a perfect stay.

Explore Brenda's Featured Key West Real Estate


1220 Von Phister Street, Key West, FL

3 Bedrooms | 3 Bathrooms | Single Family

Details Compare


1120 Olivia St., Key West, FL

2 Bedrooms | 2.5 Bathrooms | Condo

Details Compare


1514 19th Street, Key West, FL 33040

2 Bedrooms | 2 Bathrooms | Single Family

Details Compare


1207-09 William Street, Key West, FL 33040

0 Bedrooms | 0 Bathrooms | , Condo

Details Compare


1316 Villa Mill Lane, Key West, FL

4 Bedrooms | 4 full/2 half Bathrooms | Single Family

Details Compare


923 Angela, Key West, FL

2 Bedrooms | 2 Bathrooms | Single Family

Details Compare


1708 United, Key West, FL

3 Bedrooms | 2 Bathrooms | Single Family

Details Compare


619 Simonton, Key West, FL

2 Bedrooms | 2.5 Bathrooms | Single Family

Details Compare


1105 Petronia Street, Key West, FL

3 Bedrooms | 2 Bathrooms |

Details Compare


625 Eaton St., Key West, FL

3 Bedrooms | 3 Bathrooms | Single Family

Details Compare


611 William Street, Key West, FL

5 Bedrooms | 5 Bathrooms | Single Family

Details Compare


730 Southard St., Key West, FL

11 Bedrooms | 10.5 Bathrooms | Single Family

Details Compare