Walk our Key West Neighborhoods
Before you begin your search, choose a perfect Key West neighborhood. We'll explain the best features in each neighborhood so you can match your style with your new neighbors. Click the link above to get started on your neighborhood tour.
What Brenda's Clients Say
Brenda Donnelly serves her clients as though they were friends. She's beside them each step, whether they're buyers or sellers, ensuring a smooth process from the first conversation to the final celebrations. Want to hear directly from her clients? Just click the link above.

1220 Von Phister | Sophisticated retreat

Built in 1901 from ship timbers, the sophisticated, 2,064 square-foot, two-story home is the perfect retreat for a family or couple who loves to entertain. In addition to the living, dining and kitchen areas, the main floor includes a large bedroom, a full bathroom and access to the side deck.

Upstairs either of the two magnificent bedrooms with tiled ensuite baths could be considered the master suite. The magnificent main master with its three large closets opens through French doors onto its own private balcony overlooking the grounds and pool. Large windows open onto the front of the home from the second master.

The home is centered on a 3,920 square-foot property, which provides entertaining space at the back. The large, landscaped front yard is the setting for a delightful private front porch perfect for rocking away the hours.

Recent upgrades to this beautifully maintained residence include the new pool, new roof, new air conditioning system, plumbing and electrical, a whole-home generator and new furnishings.

Contact us for a private showing. 

Brenda Donnelly named Key West 2017 Realtor of the Year

Key West Realtor of the Year | BRENDA DONNELLY | REALTOR OF THE YEAR! | Here’s what her coworkers at Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Knight & Gardner Realty had to say: “Join us in congratulating Brenda Donnelly on being the 2017 Key West Realtor of the Year! Congratulations on this well deserved honor! We’re all so proud of you, we can’t imagine anyone more deserving!”

Let Brenda Donnelly find your perfect Key West real estate

Whether you want to spend a week in Key West, a month or a lifetime, Realtor Brenda Donnelly will help you navigate the single family and commercial Key West real estate markets or find a vacation rental.

Brenda DonnellyBrenda Donnelly is an award-winning, veteran Key West real estate agent and long-time resident. She brings more than two-decades of experience to your search for the perfect single family home, vacation rental or commercial property. Brenda is an agent with one of Key West’s premier luxury homes real estate companies, Berkshire Hathaway Home Services Knight & Gardner Realty,

  • Island Homes Key West will find your perfect home or business;
  • Historic Key West Vacation Rentals offers vacation rentals from a few days to a full season;
  • Inn Touch In Key West is our concierge service that will help you plan a perfect stay.

Explore Brenda's Featured Key West Real Estate


1402 Olivia #2, Key West, FL

1 Bedrooms | 1 Bathrooms | Condo

Details Compare


3312 Northside Drive #116, Key West, FL

2 Bedrooms | 2 Bathrooms | Condo

Details Compare


1211 Laird , Key West, FL

0 Bedrooms | 0 Bathrooms |

Details Compare


819 Elizabeth Street, Key West, FL

2 Bedrooms | 1.5 Bathrooms | Single Family

Details Compare


1220 Von Phister Street, Key West, FL

3 Bedrooms | 3 Bathrooms | Single Family

Details Compare


1120 Olivia St., Key West, FL

2 Bedrooms | 2.5 Bathrooms | Condo

Details Compare


1316 Villa Mill Lane, Key West, FL

4 Bedrooms | 4 full/2 half Bathrooms | Single Family

Details Compare


923 Angela, Key West, FL

2 Bedrooms | 2 Bathrooms | Single Family

Details Compare


1105 Petronia Street, Key West, FL

3 Bedrooms | 2 Bathrooms |

Details Compare


625 Eaton St., Key West, FL

3 Bedrooms | 3 Bathrooms | Single Family

Details Compare


611 William Street, Key West, FL

5 Bedrooms | 5 Bathrooms | Single Family

Details Compare


730 Southard St., Key West, FL

11 Bedrooms | 10.5 Bathrooms | Single Family

Details Compare