Skip To Content

LET THE BRENDA DONNELLY GROUP FIND YOUR PERFECT HOME IN KEY WEST

Headshot Whether you want to spend a week in Key West, a month or a lifetime, Realtor Brenda Donnelly and The Donnelly Group will help you navigate the single family and commercial Key West real estate markets. Brenda Donnelly, the 2017-18 Key West Realtor of the Year, is an experienced Key West real estate agent and long-time resident. She brings more than two decades of experience to your search for the perfect single-family home, vacation rental or commercial property. Brenda is a Luxury Collection Specialist for Berkshire Hathaway Home Services Knight & Gardner Realty, putting her among the most elite of real estate professionals. The Donnelly Group can assist you in all aspects of buying or selling a home in Key West. Historic Key West Vacation Rentals, manages high-end vacation homes for many of her real estate clients. Being able to find and manage your vacation home with clarity and ease. Brenda specializes in elegant single-family residences, superior second homes and commercially exceptional vacation investment properties.
  • Extensive experience as a luxury residential specialist handling the sale and marketing of multi-million-dollar properties in Key West
  • Second home vacation rental expert in handling and managing Key West vacation rentals
  • Expertise in zoning, licensing, permitting, financing and negotiation that make her a lead facilitator in the closing process for residential and commercial sales


Testimonials

Brenda is a spectacular agent who puts her client’s needs above everything. We have bought several properties with her and she was able to counsel, negotiate and bring to fruition our desires and dreams. We have and will continue to recommend her to friends without reservation.
Nancy & Carl: Bought a Single Family home in Old Town, Key West, FL.
Brenda Donnelly and her team are second to none when it comes to Key West real estate! My expectations were exceeded every step of the way — and the process is long — as Brenda and her team kept my best interest at heart. Brenda’s keen knowledge of the housing inventory (past and present) was critical in the process. Even post closing, Brenda continues to impress us with her connections and recommendations.
user5069866 Bought a Single Family home in Old Town, Key West, FL.
Brenda and her team were phenomenal. We can’t say enough positive things about the team and our experience working with them. They were incredibly responsive, helpful, patient, knowledgeable, etc. No request was or is too much. She is not just trying to sell a house. She listens, demonstrates she cares and works hard for you as a client. She builds a relationship with you and works as an advocate for you. She works to find the best match for you. She does not pressure you. She educates you wher…
Jill & Mindy: Bought a Single Family home at the Golf Club in Key West, FL.
We first hired Brenda and her team in 2012 after interviewing multiple realtors in Key West to help us with marketing and management of a rental property. We were impressed with her knowledge of the local market and her plan to increase our income. She delivered. In mid 2014 we asked her to find a second rental property in Old Town Key West. Once more, she found us a property that she felt was underpriced relative to peers. Once more she was right and we have been able to both increase prices an…
Euclid: Bought and sold a Single Family home in Key West, FL.
Brenda was incredibly professional and personable. She had an excellent grasp of the market and found us our Key West dream home where other agents had failed us. And when the sale hit some bumps as often happens when buying real estate, Brenda went above and beyond to make everything right and ensure we got our home!
Heather: Bought a Single Family home in Bahama Village, Key West, FL.
I purchased my first home, I used Brenda Donnelly because of local referrals. I have to say that I would never use another real estate agent other than Brenda for any future sales or purchases. She went well beyond what any normal agent would do. She has sold multiple homes to business associates of mine and they all have the same high regard for Brenda’s work ethic and professionalism. Her knowledge of the local market coupled with the business side of real estate are second to none. She has be…
Bill: Bought a Single Family home in Key West, FL.

Bought a home in 2020 in Key West. Review for Member: Kelli Houze

Local knowledge
Process expertise
Responsiveness
Negotiation skills
“Helped us find the perfect historic Key West house. Kelly was very attentive throughout the entire process She helped with obstacles that came up and was a great negotiator”
11/06/2020 - mattrmcbrayer

Bought a home in 2021 in Key West, FL. Review for Member: Jessica M. Prescott

Local knowledge
Process expertise
Responsiveness
Negotiation skills
“The service provided by Jessica during the process was impeccable. Her knowledge of the market, patience and sense of urgency was key for us to find the right property. We highly recommend Jessica not only for her vast expertise but also her personal touch and honest desire to help you find the perfect property was greatly appreciated.…
07/29/2021 - vanessaperezlopez11
Brenda was invaluable to the home buying process. She was responsive, knowledgeable, and accessible. Not being from the area, but knowing that I wanted a home with specific criteria, Brenda was able to guide us to the right neighborhood for what we wanted. She kept us informed throughout the process which resulted in us finding the perfect house!
Thomas: Bought a Single Family home in Casa Marina, Key West, FL.
Brenda brokered the sale of our Key West Florida house. We were extremely satisfied with her knowledge of the market and the “beyond the call of duty” steps she took which lead to a successful sale.
Irwin & Gary: Sold a Single Family home in Historic Seaport, Key West, FL.